Timeline of records and deadlines after a tractor-trailer crash

From TruckAccidentLawyer.wiki, a sourced reference on large-truck crashes

Timeline of records and deadlines after a tractor-trailer crash
Shortest record periodDriver vehicle inspection reports, 3 months[1]
Duty-status recordsAt least 6 months from receipt[2]
Georgia injury lawsuitsGenerally two years after the right of action accrues[3]

Several periods begin to run after a tractor-trailer crash. Some govern the motor carrier, such as post-accident testing and the minimum time it must keep particular records. Others govern the injured person, such as the time allowed to file a lawsuit. This entry sets out the carrier's periods first, from shortest to longest, and then the filing periods, using the federal motor carrier safety regulations and Georgia statutes as reference points.[4][2][3]

See also: Carrier records, preservation and spoliation

None of the federal periods is a deadline for the injured person, and none depends on whether anyone has hired a lawyer. The retention periods are minimums for a carrier's routine recordkeeping; the testing windows govern when required tests must be attempted. Whether a record must be kept longer because a claim is foreseeable is a separate legal question, discussed below.[2][5][6]

Contents

The first hours: post-accident testing

Section 382.303 requires an employer to test its surviving driver after a covered crash involving a death. It also requires testing after certain injury or tow-away crashes when the driver receives a citation for a moving violation arising from the crash. If a required alcohol test is not given within two hours, the employer must record why, and attempts stop after eight hours. Attempts at a controlled-substances test stop after 32 hours. The resulting test records are kept far longer, as the table below shows.[4][7]

See also: Commercial driver drug and alcohol testing

Minimum retention periods for carrier records

The shortest periods apply to records made in the ordinary course of a trip. Driver vehicle inspection reports, with the certification of repairs, must be kept for three months from the date the report was prepared. Records of duty status and their supporting documents must be kept for at least six months. Supporting documents include bills of lading, dispatch records, expense receipts, fleet-management communications and payroll records.[1][2][8]

See also: Electronic logging devices and duty-status records

Other records last longer. Maintenance and inspection records must be kept for one year where the vehicle is housed or maintained, and for six months after it leaves the carrier's control. A periodic inspection report is kept for 14 months. The accident register covers three years after each accident, and a driver qualification file is generally kept while the driver is employed and for three years afterward.[5][9][10][11]

See also: Truck inspection, repair and maintenance

Minimum retention periods for carrier records[1][2][8][5][7][9][10][11]
RecordRegulationMinimum federal period
Driver vehicle inspection report49 CFR 396.113 months from preparation
Records of duty status and supporting documents49 CFR 395.8 and 395.11At least 6 months from receipt
Maintenance and inspection records49 CFR 396.31 year where housed or maintained; 6 months after the vehicle leaves the carrier's control
Negative drug results and alcohol results below 0.0249 CFR 382.4011 year
Periodic inspection report49 CFR 396.2114 months from the report date
Accident register49 CFR 390.153 years after each accident
Driver qualification file49 CFR 391.51Length of employment plus 3 years
Positive drug results, alcohol results of 0.02 or more, and test refusals49 CFR 382.4015 years

Retention periods and the duty to preserve

A retention period sets how long a carrier must keep a record in the ordinary course. It does not settle whether the carrier may discard that record after an injury crash. In Phillips v. Harmon, the Supreme Court of Georgia explained that the duty to preserve relevant evidence arises when litigation is reasonably foreseeable to the party controlling it. Notice from the injured person is one route, but the Court also pointed to circumstances such as the type and extent of the injury and the defendant's own investigation and notice to its insurer.[6]

A preservation letter from the injured person's side is a direct form of that notice and can name the vehicles, electronic data and records to be kept. The letter does not prove what existed or what was lost. A trial court deciding a spoliation question has wide discretion and rules on the facts of the case.[6]

See also: Engine control modules and electronic crash evidence

One firm's stated practice

Flanagan Law's truck-accident page says its attorneys send a spoliation letter in the first week, and sometimes on the first day, demanding that the trucking company preserve black box data, driver logs, dash camera footage and maintenance records. The page states that trucking companies are allowed to erase some of that material on a schedule. Those statements describe the firm's own practice; the periods in this entry come from the regulations cited above.[12]

See also: Flanagan Law truck-accident practice

Filing deadlines and notice to governments

For a lawsuit, Georgia's general period for injuries to the person is two years after the right of action accrues, subject to exceptions, and the period for damage to personal property such as a vehicle is four years. A claim against a government body comes with earlier requirements: a claim against a city must be presented in writing within six months of the event, a claim against a county within 12 months after it accrues, with a separate period for minors and others under a disability, and a state tort claim needs written notice within 12 months after the loss was or should have been discovered. The city and state statutes also set requirements for what the notice contains and how it is delivered.[3][13][14][15][16]

See also: Georgia truck-crash law notes

How the periods compare

The federal retention periods and the state filing periods do not line up. A lawsuit filed well inside the two-year period can still come after the three-month and six-month record periods have ended. Discovery in a filed case is the formal process through which the parties exchange documents, but it can reach only what still exists.[17][1][2][3]

The sources in this entry set periods for carriers and claimants; none sets a time for hiring a lawyer, and this entry does not suggest one. The table shows what can change while that question is open: testing windows close within 32 hours, routine trip and inspection records can reach the end of their required retention within months, and most filing deadlines run in years, with earlier notice requirements for claims against governments.[4][1][2][3]

See also: Truck-crash claims and litigation costs

References

  1. abcde "49 CFR 396.11: Driver vehicle inspection reports". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  2. abcdefg "49 CFR 395.8: Driver record of duty status". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  3. abcde "O.C.G.A. 9-3-33: Personal-injury limitations". Georgia General Assembly, code reproduced by Justia. Official source. Checked . Source record
  4. abc "49 CFR 382.303: Post-accident testing". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  5. abc "49 CFR 396.3: Inspection, repair and maintenance". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  6. abc "Phillips v. Harmon, 297 Ga. 386 (2015)". Supreme Court of Georgia, reproduced by Justia. Official source. Checked . Source record
  7. ab "49 CFR 382.401: Retention of drug and alcohol testing records". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  8. ab "49 CFR 395.11: Supporting documents". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  9. ab "49 CFR 396.21: Periodic inspection recordkeeping". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  10. ab "49 CFR 390.15: Accident records". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  11. ab "49 CFR 391.51: Driver qualification files". Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register and GPO. Official source. Checked . Source record
  12. ^ "Truck Accident Lawyer Atlanta". Flanagan Law, P.C. Firm-published source. Checked . Source record
  13. ^ "O.C.G.A. 9-3-31: Injury to personal property". Georgia General Assembly, code reproduced by Justia. Official source. Checked . Source record
  14. ^ "O.C.G.A. 36-33-5: Notice of claims against municipalities". Georgia General Assembly, code reproduced by FindLaw. Official source. Checked . Source record
  15. ^ "O.C.G.A. 36-11-1: Presenting claims against counties". Georgia General Assembly, code reproduced by FindLaw. Official source. Checked . Source record
  16. ^ "O.C.G.A. 50-21-26: Notice of tort claims against the state". Georgia General Assembly, code reproduced by Justia. Official source. Checked . Source record
  17. ^ "Civil Cases". Administrative Office of the United States Courts. Official source. Checked . Source record